Free in-home measure and quote - PGT, CGI and CWS impact lines compared on your actual openings, style by style
New Construction Windows vs Replacement Windows: What Actually Makes Sense for a West Palm Beach House
For most homes built before 2002 in West Palm Beach, replacement windows are the right call because they’re made to fit inside your existing concrete-block openings without tearing out interior drywall, stucco, or trim. New construction windows only make sense when walls are already open down to the studs, typically during an addition or full gut renovation. Call (561) 264-1279 and we’ll tell you which one your house actually needs, based on how it was built, not on which product carries the bigger margin.
Why This Decision Gets Tricky in West Palm Beach
Most of the window comparison articles on the internet were written for wood-framed houses in the Midwest. They describe nailing flanges, house wrap, and exterior sheathing you can peel back like a Band-Aid. None of that applies here. West Palm Beach’s dominant housing stock is 1940s to 1980s CBS construction, concrete block walls with stucco over them, and a lot of it still carries original aluminum jalousie or single-pane slider windows that predate every code worth mentioning.
When a house in Flamingo Park or El Cid still has its original jalousies, the question isn’t really “new construction or replacement.” The question is whether the window opening can accept a modern impact-rated unit without a masonry crew. The answer is usually yes, through Window Installation methods built around a retrofit flange, but the distinction matters a great deal when you’re comparing bids.
The Practical Difference Between the Two
If you’re weighing new construction windows vs replacement windows from a desk, without a wall open in front of you, the choice comes down to how much wall you intend to disrupt:
- Replacement windows are measured to fit inside the existing frame. The old sashes and tracks come out, the new unit goes in, and the interior trim and exterior stucco stay put. This is how 95 out of 100 window upgrades in West Palm Beach should be done.
- New construction windows have a nailing flange meant to be fastened to bare framing before drywall, sheathing, or stucco goes on. They’re a wall-open product. If your walls aren’t open, installing one means opening them, and that’s a renovation project, not a window project.
What Concrete Block Construction Changes
In a wood-framed house, a replacement window anchors into wood. In a CBS house, it anchors into a concrete opening, often one that hasn’t been touched since the Eisenhower administration. The trick is measuring the opening’s actual square, because concrete block shifts. If the opening is out of square by half an inch, a poorly measured replacement window will bind, leak, or refuse to seat properly against the sealant beads.
When Replacement Windows Are the Right Answer
Here’s the honest framework we give homeowners who call the shop:
- The stucco is intact and the interior trim is staying. A replacement window lets you leave both alone. Most jobs finish in a single visit.
- The opening size is staying the same. If you’re not enlarging or relocating the opening, there’s no reason to strip the wall down to framing to install a flanged window.
- You need impact glass that qualifies for insurance credits. Replacement units made by PGT, ES Windows, ECO Window Systems, or Mr-Glass can be engineered and tested for Palm Beach County’s wind-borne debris region. The retrofit method doesn’t reduce their rating.
- You live in a historic district. In Flamingo Park and El Cid, the City’s Historic Preservation Board must approve any exterior window that alters the visible profile. Simulated divided-light impact windows, made as replacement units, replicate original muntin patterns far more cleanly than new construction flanges ever could.
When New Construction Windows Make Sense
If you’re already adding a room, pushing out a rear wall, or converting a carport into conditioned space, those new walls will be bare block or framing. That’s when a new construction window with a proper nailing flange goes in before the stucco crew arrives. The window is set plumb and square against the rough framing, and the flange gets integrated into the wall assembly so water never finds a path behind it.
We also see new construction windows specified in full-gut renovations where the owner is replacing every mechanical system anyway and the drywall is already down. If the wall is open, use the flange. If it isn’t, don’t open it just for the flange. That’s the whole decision.
A Side-by-Side Look at the Tradeoff
| Factor | Replacement Windows | New Construction Windows |
|---|---|---|
| Wall disruption | Minimal, interior and stucco stay intact | Requires open wall or full renovation |
| Labor on a CBS house | Moderate, anchor into existing concrete opening | High, needs framing prep and masonry work |
| Typical timeline, West Palm Beach | 1 day for most openings | 3 to 7 days, including finish work |
| Impact-rating eligibility | Yes, tested retrofit units available | Yes, flanged impact units available |
| Historic district approval | Often simpler, profile matches original | More complicated, opening alteration triggers review |
| Cost per opening | Generally lower, less finish work | Generally higher, includes wall repair |
What We Tell Homeowners About Insurance and Code
In West Palm Beach, the choice between new construction windows and replacement windows isn’t just about wall surgery. It’s about keeping your insurance policy alive. Palm Beach County sits in a wind-borne debris region with a design wind speed exceeding 160 mph. Florida Building Code requires every window and door opening to use a tested impact-rated product or an approved hurricane protection system. There is no waiver pathway for residential replacement work.
Florida’s ongoing insurance crunch turned this from a building code matter into a financial one. Citizens Insurance and private carriers have been issuing non-renewal notices or steep premium hikes to policyholders who cannot document wind mitigation upgrades. For many of the pre-2002 CBS homes we see in Northwood and Flamingo Park, original jalousie windows are a liability on paper, not just a nuisance on a hot afternoon. Replacing them with impact-rated units, whether retrofit or new construction, is the documentable fix.
We register both manufacturer warranty layers in writing before the technician leaves your driveway, and the Done Right Promise covers the workmanship. If the pane is not true, the job is not done.
Common West Palm Beach Scenarios
This is where the new construction vs replacement question actually lands, in the field, on real houses:
The 1960s Ranch in Northwood with Original Jalousies
The homeowner wants impact windows, has a Citizens renewal letter in hand, and doesn’t want to lose the mid-century look. We specify a replacement impact casement or fixed unit sized to the existing opening, keep the interior trim, and the whole job runs one day per opening. No stucco repair, no drywall dust, no reason to open the wall.
The 1920s Mediterranean in El Cid
Original steel casements, visible muntin bars, and a Historic Preservation Board application with a 6 to 10 week lead time. We specify simulated divided-light impact replacement windows sized to preserve the opening’s proportions. The approval process is slower than the install, which is why we tell people to start the paperwork before they even pick their glass package.
The Canal-Front House with Salt Air on the Windows
Living a block off Lake Worth Lagoon puts salt spray on every metal surface. Homeowners near the water often ask whether they should replace windows or move to new construction openings for better sealing. The honest answer: a properly measured and flashed replacement window, installed with marine-grade sealant against a clean concrete opening, will seal every bit as well as a flanged unit. The opening preparation matters more than the flange.
The Addition Going Up in the Backyard
This is the one case where new construction windows are the automatic answer. New block walls, new rough openings, new stucco going over everything. Flanged impact windows go in before the stucco crew arrives, set square and sealed against the house wrap. Window Installation in West Palm Beach for an addition is a different animal than a retrofit, and we quote it as such.
How the Quote Process Works
We measure every opening twice. Then we quote manufacturer lines side by side on paper, Andersen alongside PGT alongside ES Windows, so you see the actual price difference between products instead of trusting a salesperson’s summary. If you’re replacing ten windows in a CBS house, we’ll tell you which openings are candidates for retrofit and which, if any, are better served by a flanged unit because the surrounding stucco has failed or the opening has shifted.
We don’t charge for that assessment. A live person answers the phone 24 hours a day, seven days a week, and if you call, you’ll get Dale or one of our technicians on the line, not a voicemail tree and not a regional call center. The local pro is background-checked, uniformed, and works in your house the way we’d work in our own mother’s.
FAQs
You need replacement windows if your existing wall openings are staying the same size and the walls aren’t being opened down to the studs; you need new construction windows only if you’re building a new wall, adding a room, or doing a full gut renovation where the framing is exposed. In West Palm Beach, the answer for most existing CBS homes is replacement.
Impact-rated replacement windows in West Palm Beach typically run $900 to $2,400 per opening installed, depending on size, product line, and existing framing condition. A standard 36-inch by 60-inch impact single-hung in a retrofitted CBS opening will usually fall between $1,100 and $1,800 with installation and permit, though historic district approval can add cost in El Cid or Flamingo Park. Call (561) 264-1279 for a quote against your actual measurements, not a range printed on a website.
Yes, replacement windows can be impact-rated and installed in a retrofit application that meets Florida Building Code for Palm Beach County’s wind-borne debris region. The test rating belongs to the window and its anchoring system, not to whether it has a nailing flange or a retrofit frame.
For original aluminum jalousie or single-pane sliders in a pre-2002 West Palm Beach home, replacement is usually cheaper in the long run because the old units cannot be made impact-rated and don’t qualify for insurance wind mitigation credits. Replacing fogged glass or re-sealing a leaky frame costs less upfront, but doesn’t solve the code or insurance problem. We offer a maintenance check for homeowners who need another year or two before committing, and we’ll tell you honestly when a window is worth saving and when it isn’t.
If you’d rather have it looked at, TruePane Windows & Doors offers a no-pressure assessment in West Palm Beach. Call (561) 264-1279 and we’ll measure, quote, and tell you the truth about which window type your house actually needs. Done right, in writing, on the first visit.
Written by TruePane Windows & Doors, TruePane Windows & Doors at TruePane Windows & Doors, serving West Palm Beach, FL.
Six Reasons Homeowners Choose TruePane Windows & Doors
Impact systems engineered to design pressures up to +/-100, matched to your wind zone - your openings hold when the storm arrives.
Low-E insulated impact glass from our manufacturer lines commonly cuts monthly cooling bills 20-30%.
Laminated impact glass shuts out up to 40% of outside noise - traffic, neighbors, weather.
Monitoring services run $30-90 a month. Laminated impact glass resists forced entry around the clock, with no subscription.
Florida homeowners average around 25% savings on the windstorm portion of their policy after protecting every opening - some homes qualify for more.
A full impact package upgrades curb appeal, buyer confidence and appraised value in one project.



Before
After
Before
After
Before
After